Source One
https://www.quora.com/How-would-you-describe-Light-Yagamis-psychological-profile-in-Death-Note-Is-he-a-sociopath-a-psychopath-or-something-else
Presentation
A bit messy, with different colours of fonts, but reasonable font size.
Relevance Does relate to overall topic, being a discussion relating to an anime
character, and potential underlying mental health issues that may explain their
behaviour.
Objectivity Is a multiple expression of opinion, with the main point of referencing
being Wiki, so not objective, and not correctly evidenced. People expressing opinions
do not indicate they are “qualified” to comment on mental health, as do not indicate they
are currently practising mental health professionals, but still an interesting discussion.
This is quite an abstract idea. No one would make a diagnosis on the basis of observing
behaviour described in a comic book, after all.
Methodology N/A
Provenance Good. Descriptions, of authors, and qualifications.
Timeliness 2017, so within the last 8 years.
Source Two
https://casuistor.tumblr.com/post/149988857881/re-light-yagamis-presumed-sociopathy-and-why-he
Presentation Font size too small.
Relevance Does relate to overall topic, being a discussion relating to an anime
character, and potential underlying mental health issues that may explain their
behaviour.
Objectivity An interesting counter argument, with elements of research but no stated
author. Or referencing. Draws upon American research, so potentially American.
Methodology N/A
Provenance Poor. No clearly stated author. But well argued, with no overwhelming
bias. This is a discussion about a fictional character. Interesting level of self awareness
as states “the ability to read articles and checklists online does not translate into
academic or clinical literacy.”, and that they are not a medical professional but someone
with insight as they state “have had half a year of clinical psych is more exposure than
is typical”, suggesting they have accessed clinical psychology themselves, rather than
being a mental health practitioner.
No comments:
Post a Comment